Public interest immunity in protecting informants
When deciding whether material withheld by the prosecution on the ground of public-interest immunity should be disclosed in the interests of justice, a trial judge would rule in favour of . Recent public interest immunity cases give useful guidance for government entities who may be contemplating a claim in the future document production in litigation presents many challenges for public agencies, there can be an additional problem: while disclosing documents might be in a party's . Public-interest immunity and drug dealers where the identity of paid police informants could be at risk sought by the british government to protect . 146 savage v chief constable of hampshire  public interest immunity evidence of police informants - whether immunity may be waived at the instigation of the informant savage v chief constable of hampshire february 14 1997 court of appeal (civil division) (leggatt lj, potter lj, judge lj) the facts the plaintiff claimed he had acted as a police informer under an agreement made-with a . The attorney general's guidelines regarding the use of confidential informants prohffiition on commitments of immunity by federal or local public officials.
It concludes by proposing a novel solution for ex parte public interest immunity claims this article asserts that rather than relying on prosecutors acting as ‘ministers of justice’ or special advocates to protect an accused’s interests, courts should entrust defence lawyers to represent the accused at ex parte public interest immunity . Public interest immunity page 4 of 11 and (iii) why limited or partial disclosure would not meet the public interest concern and protect the defendant’s right to a fair trial the written application has to set out the material over which pii is sought. Protecting rights home about or sooner if a public interest immunity process is concluded first a review into ruc special branch and the handling of . Immunity attaches to informants’ communications with mps under specific circum- stances 2 ) and strengthening the whistleblowers protection act 1994 (qld) or the parliament of queensland act to provide for protected public interest disclosures to.
What next for public interest immunity public interest immunity and police informants’ the investigating team to protect its informant, coupled with an . Medical practitioners board of victoria while there was certainly a public interest in protecting medical confidentiality, providing for confidentiality did not . Public interest and immunity in this paper, the justifications for the existence of public interest immunity will be examined for the protection of informants . Public interest immunity certificates for the protection of informants must be used only carefully the crown must specify the purpose of the public interest immunity certificate.
Further, while there is no doubt that the immunity serves a useful purpose in protecting the public interest in confidentiality (in this instance protecting police informants and sources of . Public interest immunity 1 the court must balance the nature of the injury which the nation or public service would be likely to suffer with the evidentiary value and importance of the documents in the particular litigation. Public protection: informants contents 1 of law enforcement to provide protection to informants against was entitled to qualified immunity, that the .
Public interest immunity in protecting informants
A chinese dissident and mi6 informant has lost a long battle to when a witness provided new evidence after reading an article in the guardian signed public interest immunity certificates . Interest immunity available to police in preventing the disclosure of intelligence information it has been established that a balance need occur between the need to protect the interests of the accused and the ability of police. A public-interest immunity certificate was sought by the home secretary jacqui smith it was reported by the times on 13 december 2007 that the grounds were on the basis of protecting national security interests and to protect the identity of informants. Chapter 8 public interest immunity 81 introduction in order to establish the liability of a party to an action or, indeed, to establish one’s defence to an action, it may be necessary to request relevant documentation from the opposing party.
Public interest immunity (pii) is a doctrine utilized in british common law when it is believed that the disclosure of certain information could be detrimental to public safety. Case law update - disclosure and public interest immunity thirty nine essex street provided sufficient safeguards to protect the proper interests of the board, the contributing agencies and .
Although it is almost invisible to the public, the use of criminal informants is everywhere in the us justice system informants with so little protection, they . This essay aimed to explore the role of public interest immunity in protecting informants as a class it can be concluded from the discussion that this. Police want law to protect informants the courts could no longer be relied upon to rule that the police had public interest immunity over the identities of informants . Police informants - 467/15 no requirement to consider the public interest in disclosure tasked with protecting the community we serve and solving crime and .